the HAES files: call up your surly adolescent

by Health At Every Size® Blog

by Deb Burgard, PhD

In late June the FDA announced they would start placing gruesome photos on packs of cigarettes to depict “the negative health consequences of smoking.”  They apparently did research to find out which images were the most memorable and disturbing, but they failed to do research that demonstrated such images had any influence on quitting behavior – or, for that matter, buying behavior.

I can guess that this is exactly the sort of “intervention” that will backfire spectacularly, especially with teenagers.  Call up your inner Surly Adolescent, and what is her reaction to gore and guts and diseased lungs on a cigarette package?  “Bring. It. On!”  There will be competitions for who gets the grossest packs, which brands have the most disgusting pictures, and general “You Are Not the Boss of Me” behavior that is now even more compelling since she’s now here to prove a point.

So why do public health agencies continue to use money on corporate marketing techniques, rather than seeing what actually affects the frequency of quitting attempts and the length of smoking cessation following quitting? 

The parallels with messages about fear-and-loathing of fatness are striking.  In both cases, the authorities within public health agencies continue to assume that fear messages change behavior.  But the declines in overall smoking occurred during the period when laws were enacted banning smoking in most public places, while the fear messages have been a constant drumbeat for decades.  Behavior changes when environments make specific behaviors more inconvenient, or more convenient.   Punishing, on the other hand, has been shown over and over to result in unpredictable outcomes, often an increase in the behaviors targeted for elimination.

If we want people  – of all sizes – to do the practices that support health, like quitting smoking, moving their bodies, sleeping restfully, getting good medical care, eating better fuel for their bodies, loving and feeling loved, we need to make it easier to do those things.  We need to make access to those practices something available to anyone at any time, not just wealthy people with plenty of time on their hands.  And we need to help all people feel like they are worth this effort.  Instead we are practicing a policy of shaming and threatening, a message of, “if you look like this, you’re a loser.”  And we shouldn’t be surprised that people react to being shunned with anger and rebellion.

I actually love that most of us have an Inner Surly Adolescent, because she is the guardian of freedom, a True Patriot, and the surprising source of a lot of our mental health.  Surly Adolescents fight against rejection, bullsh*t, and tyranny.  But they have a vulnerability, which is that they tend to be surprisingly manipulate-able.  They do the opposite of what they’re being coerced or nagged to do, whether they want to do that behavior or not. 

So the Surly Adolescent, who might love to dance, will sit with her arms crossed on the sofa watching TV if she is told she should exercise.  She might love cantaloupe but if that’s what the diet allows, it will be the last thing she wants when she is proving that she gets to eat whatever she wants. 

So if you want her to thrive and use her energy for good, the last thing to do is use coercion or shaming, or even fear.  You have to show her respect.

We just adopted a couple wonderful little dogs.  Taking them to “obedience school” (what a throwback that phrase is) has been a great review of behavioral learning theory.  The course teaches the humans to think about how to arrange the environment so that it is easier for the dog to do what you are asking than not to.  It teaches the humans not to ask the dog to do something that isn’t realistic.  It reminds humans to keep the faith that the dog would rather find a way to behave that results in happiness and harmony.   I would like to send anyone who makes public health policy through obedience school. 

I think they would come out a lot more interested in Health at Every SizeSM.

5 Comments to “the HAES files: call up your surly adolescent”

  1. Oh wow! This is such an awesome post Deb and I totally agree. It seems to mesh so well with my experience of the world. Maybe we at ASDAH could create a task force to work in this direction.

    Thanks for making my day!
    Jeanette DePatie

  2. I’m personally really tired of people comparing fatness to smoking or drugs or drinking or anything else. Firstly because fatness is rarely a choice while these other things are. It reinforces the idea that you can just quit fat the same way you quit smoking. Secondly because it reinforces the idea that fat is unhealthy just like these other things. Thirdly, things like smoking effect the health of others. People smoke around strangers, family members, friends, *children*, and expose them to second hand smoke. As a child there was so much smoke in my house at all times (4 chain smokers) that when my mom finally moved us to our own house (and quit smoking herself) the sudden lack of constant cigarette smoke had an effect on me- i had cravings (at six years old, mind you) for cigarettes (and still do to this day when I”m stressed enough though I’ve never touched a cigarette myself), I had dreams about smoking. In other words, I went through withdrawal. Now cigarette smoke makes me sick to my stomach, gives me migraines, and makes me cough. Somehow, if I suddenly found myself no longer around fat people I don’t think I’d have any adverse physical effects. Now, I have no problems with people choosing to do things which are unhealthy- my problems come from it effecting others. If that weren’t an issue I wouldn’t care a lick.. but it’s still nothing like fatness. I choose to drink, I did not choose to be fat and I am not unhealthy because of it (as I would be if I CHOSE to smoke).

  3. I teach in a Master’s Program on Holistic Health Education. I emphasize to my students that a holistic approach to health education is rooted in empowering our clients to make their own choices and to define for themselves what health means. Please don’t let the word out that all my students need to do is attend dog obedience school — I will be out of a job!

    But seriously, folks…. Long live the Inner Surly Adolescent in each of us…literally. I think people with strong Inner Surly Adolescents probably DO live longer!

    I’d like to do a survey of people who have a good quality of life over age 90 and I would bet that they would all rank extremely high on whatever scale you could come up with to measure rebelliousness. These are the people who say “hell, no” to the doctors and public health officials who tell them how limited they should feel by their age or their disease or their size or their health condition. In other words, these are the people who are not vulnerable to the pervasive “nocebo” effect that our blaming, shaming culture attempts to infict on anyone outside the “norm.” In fact these are the people who don’t accept the concept of “norm” or that there is any benefit to conforming to it. I want to be one of these people!

  4. Brilliant! It does remind one of the old saw about a parent cautioning their kid to “not put beans up your nose.” And what is the first thing the kid tries?

    I saw a male teenager at the village green today. He had a bored, surly, disenchanted expression. I doubt whether the messages on the cigarette packages will do much to keep him from smoking. Threats of future illness and death don’t affect this bunch very much. Neither did the film “Reefer Madness” in the 1950’s, wasn’t it? When it comes to adults figuring out what motivates kids to do their bidding–there is a great generational divide, and always has been.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: